(As a mom of five who has tried everything)

I have five kids, so I have bought and gifted a LOT of toys. Some of them were great for about six days and then became living room speed bumps.

Some of them I wish I had bought in the first place instead of buying other gimmicks to get there.

Every Christmas I watch parents and relatives spend real money on stuff that gets opened, played with for a weekend, and then shoved under a bed.

Or worse, they are tossed in the trash a few weeks later by mom …when the clutter gets to be too much. 

I’ve done it too. But over the years, a pattern has emerged in our house. There are certain toys that just keep getting pulled out. Kids come back to them. Younger kids discover them after older kids have loved them for years. They survive moves and messes and a thousand rough afternoons.

These are the five I’d actually recommend.

The suggestions encourage open play with limited screens and noise. I am not recommending because they’re trendy or because the company asked me to. They didn’t. But I did use my affiliate link, so that I get a small commission off my recommendations, at no additional cost to you, which in turn helps my large Catholic family share our ideas.

Not Just a Toy – Also a School Lesson

I’m talking about the realistic animal figurines. Brands like Schleich and Safari Ltd make animals that are beautifully detailed, durable, and genuinely fun to play with across a huge age range.

My kids started playing with these as toddlers and they are still playing with them now. They build habitats, create stories, make families, sort them by continent, use them in school projects, and yes, sometimes just line them up on a shelf because they look cool. These animals also happen to be a quiet, screen-free activity that kids will reach for on their own without you suggesting it. But if they do forget about their play animals and you bring them out, it ends up being hours of occupation.

They’re also basically indestructible, which matters a lot when you have a house full of children. I’ve never had one break. That alone makes them worth every penny.

Don’t Buy Just Any Building Block

Because that’s wasteful and they aren’t all created equally. If you haven’t bought Magnatiles yet, just do it. I know they feel expensive for what they are. Buy them anyway.

These magnetic tiles have been in our house for years and they get used over and over and over. Toddlers bang them together and enjoy the colors. Older kids build increasingly complicated structures. I have seen them build a castle and then put The Little Mermaid at the top in prison. My kids have used them to make castles, barns, towers, ramps for toy cars, and enclosures for their toy animals. They connect to each other in ways that reward creativity without requiring any instruction. They’re quiet, and some days they’ll keep the kids occupied for HOURS. 

They also grow with your kids. A two-year-old and a nine-year-old can play with the same set and both be fully engaged. That kind of longevity is genuinely rare in a toy. I’d put them at the top of any gift list for a family with multiple kids.

Also – you literally can’t have enough of them. You can buy wheel attachments to build cars, princess gates for castles, different shaped triangles, the list goes on and on. 

I’d much prefer a box of new magna tiles to any other building toy.

And I’ve even used them in homeschool. 

When They’re Playing and Also Secretly Learning

This one might surprise you because it looks pretty basic. That’s actually the point.

The LeapFrog Scribble and Write is a simple electronic learning tablet that teaches kids to write their letters and numbers by tracing along a guided path with a stylus. It talks, it gives feedback, and it’s almost completely self-directed. You don’t have to sit next to your child and walk them through it. You hand it to them and they figure it out.

For a busy mom, that matters. It matters a lot. My kids used this over and over when they were learning to write, and it genuinely helped. The feedback is immediate, the repetition is built in, and it never gets frustrated with a kid who needs to try the same letter fifteen times. That’s not something I can always say about myself on a hard afternoon.

It’s also under thirty dollars most of the time, which makes it one of the best values on this list. It’s also my top toy from LeapFrog.

The Bus That Holds All The Dolls and Toys

This one has been in our family so long I’ve lost count of which kids have played with it. Little People consistently comes out with great sets (though not all I’d keep for grandkids).

The life-sized bus in particular is very flexible with other toys. It invites open-ended imaginative play. My kids have used the bus to go on trips, take their toy animals to school, carry food to pretend restaurants, and do about a hundred other things I never could have scripted.

I’ve even found my 6-8-year-olds using it for their Barbies and superheroes. But be sure to buy the larger bus – as there is also a smaller one in production – and in this case, bigger is better.

The Little People line has been around for decades because it holds up and is classic, though not all of their merch is a win. Even though this one is kind of big, its utility is unmatched. I’m not passing this one on. I’ll be saving it for when grandbabies come to visit.

The Cutest Dollhouse Animal-People that also Fit in Monster Trucks

Calico Critters is the kind of toy that I’d classify as almost unfairly good for kids. The little animal families come with tiny accessories, they fit into playsets that are sold separately, and they encourage the kind of slow, detailed, imaginative play that I think we’re losing to screens.

My kids have used Calico Critters to build elaborate little worlds. They have families, houses, routines, and stories that go on across multiple days. They’re not rushing through anything. They’re building something. That’s different from most toys, which give a kid a novelty experience and then run out of road.

The figures are small, so they work well for kids who are past the putting-everything-in-their-mouth stage. Once a child is around four or five, these become a genuinely wonderful open-ended toy that will keep them busy for hours with little fanfare.

What All Five of These Have in Common

I didn’t pick these five randomly. They share a few qualities that I’ve come to look for in a toy worth actually buying.

First, they’re open-ended. None of them tell the child exactly what to do or how to play. They invite imagination and leave room for a kid to surprise you.

Second, they span ages. Every single one of these has been loved by more than one of my kids, across a range of ages. That’s not an accident. Good toys don’t outgrow a child in a season.

Third, they’re durable. None of them are fragile, none of them require batteries that die every three days, and none of them have fallen apart under the pressure of actual children actually playing with them.

And fourth, they’re (relatively) quiet. I say that as a mom of five who deeply values a few minutes of peace. A toy that occupies a child in real, focused play without producing constant, obnoxious sounds or requiring adult participation is genuinely worth its weight in gold.

A Note on Gift-Giving This Christmas

If you’re shopping for little ones this year and you’re tempted by whatever is trending on the toy aisle right now, I’d encourage you to pause. Trends come and go fast in the toy world, and a lot of what gets marketed heavily at Christmas is designed to capture attention for about two weeks.

The toys on this list have a different quality. They grow with children. They stay interesting because children bring their own imagination to them instead of just reacting to what the toy does. And when the next little sibling comes along, or a cousin visits, or you need something to occupy a rainy afternoon in February, these are the ones that will still be there.

If you’d like to be informed of the next part of this post, please subscribe below.